GAZA CITY, Gaza Strip — When fighting erupted between Israel and the hard-line Palestinian militant group, Islamic Jihad, here earlier this month, the battle lasted just three days but it took a heavy toll: Gaza's Health Ministry said 49 Palestinians were killed, including 17 children.
Israeli officials said they were targeting Islamic Jihad members for allegedly planning attacks on Israelis. Israel wound up killing militants and civilians. Islamic Jihad responded by firing about 1,000 rockets; Israel said some of the rockets killed Gazan civilians when the projectiles fell short and landed in Gaza.
People in Gaza say they believe the violence, and duration, would have been even worse had the larger, ruling militant group, Hamas, gotten involved. But in a change of tact, Hamas sat this one out.
Since the fighting — the deadliest in Gaza since last year's 11-day war — residents are having difficult discussions about the roles of the militant groups. While many Gazans support the resistance against the Israeli government for its treatment of Palestinians, they're frustrated at Gaza's militants for problems like high unemployment and deep poverty. And some analysts see a rift forming between Hamas and Islamic Jihad, even though they pledge unity.
People want a say when war erupts
"Where is the role of the people when these factions go to war?" asks Ahmed, a 37-year-old who wants to only use his first name to speak freely without fear of reprisals from militants. "The people should have a say ... because we end up paying the price."
Ahmed is sipping tea with friends in a park in Gaza City. The park and surrounding streets have gone totally dark — because the severe power shortage often leads to blackouts here.
Ahmed says he supports the Palestinian resistance, but he blames Islamic Jihad for escalating the latest conflict in order to make a deal with Israel and free some of its prisoners.
He was glad to see Hamas stay out of the fighting. "It's possible Hamas finally realized that war brings nothing but destruction," he says.
Hamas and Islamic Jihad: partners and rivals
Hamas took over Gaza from the Palestinian Authority in 2007, leading Israel to impose heavy restrictions on goods and people transiting the strip's borders. And Gaza's rulers have fought multiple wars against Israel.
Both Hamas and Islamic Jihad are listed as terrorist organizations by the United States, the European Union, Israel and other governments, and the groups share some common ideology in wanting to create an Islamic Palestinian state.
Their official line has been to present a unified front between the two.
Yet some Gazans accuse Hamas of abandoning Islamic Jihad, even as Israel targeted and killed two of the smaller group's leaders and nearly 20 fighters this month. Israel called the operation a success that severely set back Islamic Jihad.
On Monday, Hamas and Islamic Jihad leaders met to discuss bilateral relations and released a joint statement affirming their unity, sayingand that "the resistance is the strategic choice in confronting the occupation."
However, the rivalry between the two has never been more obvious, according to Tholfekar Swairjo, a political analyst who previously was a spokesman for a secular leftist Palestinian movement.
"First of all, Hamas wants to protect its authority in the Gaza Strip," he says. "There is boiling anger in the streets against the Hamas movement. They are blamed for the very low quality of life in Gaza, and so now they don't want to engage in any war that would increase the level of anger against them from the Palestinians."
Swairjo says Hamas couldn't jeopardize recent understandings with Israel that would bring economic relief to Gaza. Thousands of Palestinians from Gaza are now allowed to work in Israel, and there has also been an increase in goods and supplies going into Gaza.
Islamic Jihad — considered more hard-line — views that as selling out.
"Islamic Jihad say economic incentives that Israel has offered to Gaza has become a knife to the neck of the armed resistance," Swairjo says.
The two militant groups are also in competition for supporters. And according to Swairjo, Hamas has lost some of its recruiting momentum to Islamic Jihad.
Unlike Hamas, which participates in elections and now governs, Swairjo says, Islamic Jihad has no political ideology or even goals beyond fighting Israel. And that can attract a lot of different groups, from Islamists to seculars and leftists.
Gazans lose hope in their future
For many Gazans, however, there's no difference between Hamas and Islamic Jihad.
At a crowded seaside terrace, 32-year-old Reham is smoking a water pipe known as a hookah with friends. She gave NPR her first name only, to be able to speak frankly about politics without fear of militant groups.
"Most Gazans have stopped believing in Hamas and the others," she says. "You know why? Because they don't feed us, they don't provide anything. You have to depend on yourself. How can we build a future with these guys? And all the back to back wars?"
The presence of the militant groups is also threatening and divisive, she adds. The fighters are often targeted by the Israelis, and civilians who live near them can become casualties.
"People have started to be afraid of where they are living, who their neighbors are, what their political leanings might be," Reham says. "It's affecting community relationships."
She and many others think it's foolish to expect stability in Gaza.
"There is no guarantee for anything in Gaza," she says. "We don't know when or why or how the war happens."
All that's known is, when war happens, she says, no one is safe, regardless of politics.
9(MDAxODcyMTgzMDEyMTgxMTY5NjYxN2I4OQ004))
Transcript
MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:
Let's head overseas now. After more violence in the Gaza Strip, Palestinians there are taking stock of the armed groups that hold so much sway over their lives. This month, Israel and Islamic Jihad traded fire for three days. Nearly 50 people died in Gaza. Militants and civilians, including some who Israel says were killed by Islamic Jihad rockets that went off course. But Hamas, the bigger party that actually governs Gaza, did not join in, and the fighting did not escalate further. NPR's Fatma Tanis talked with people in Gaza.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: (Non-English language spoken).
FATMA TANIS, BYLINE: On a balmy weekend night away from Gaza's waterfront, Ahmed is sitting at a park with his friends, sipping tea. He only gave me his first name to speak freely without reprisals from militant groups. It's completely dark out except for the occasional car headlights because of the severe power shortage here. Ahmed, like most in Gaza, still backs resistance to Israel. Both Hamas and Islamic Jihad count on many loyal supporters. But criticism is growing among Palestinians like Ahmed, who faults Islamic Jihad for escalating the latest conflict in order to make a deal with Israel and free some of its prisoners.
AHMED: (Through translator) Where is the role of the people when these factions go to war? The people should have a say because we end up paying the price.
TANIS: Ahmed is also critical of Hamas, like many others, but he says he was glad to see the group stay out of the conflict this time, which helped bring a quick end to the fighting, though nearly 50 people were killed in Gaza.
AHMED: (Through translator) It's possible Hamas finally realized that that war brings nothing but destruction.
TANIS: Hamas now has been accused by some of abandoning Islamic Jihad as Israel targeted and killed two of its leaders and nearly 20 militants. Israel called the operation a success and said it had set back the group severely. Meanwhile, Islamic Jihad put out a statement last week calling for, quote, "unity among resistance groups," which is their official line - that the two groups are partners. But Gaza political analyst with local media Tholfikar Swairjo says the rivalry between the two groups has never been more obvious.
THOLFIKAR SWAIRJO: (Through translator) First of all, Hamas wants to protect its authority in the Gaza Strip. There's boiling anger in the streets against the Hamas movement. They are blamed for the very low quality of life in Gaza. And so now, they do not want to engage in any war that would increase the level of anger against them from the Palestinians.
TANIS: He says Hamas couldn't jeopardize recent understandings with Israel that would bring economic relief to Gaza. Thousands of Palestinians from Gaza are now allowed to work in Israel, and more goods and supplies can go in. But Swairjo says Islamic Jihad, the more extreme group, sees that as selling out.
SWAIRJO: (Through translator) Islamic Jihad say economic incentives that Israel has offered to Gaza has become a knife to the neck of the armed resistance.
TANIS: Another layer is their competition for supporters. Swairjo says Hamas has lost some of its recruiting momentum to Islamic Jihad. Unlike Hamas, which participates in elections and now governs, Islamic Jihad has no political ideology or even goals beyond fighting Israel. And that can attract a lot of different groups, from Islamists to seculars and leftists. But many ordinary Gazans see no difference between the two.
At a seaside terrace, Reham is smoking a water pipe known as hookah with friends. She says most Gazans have stopped believing in Hamas and the others.
REHAM: (Non-English language spoken).
TANIS: "The presence of the militant groups here is also threatening and divisive," she says. "They're often targets of Israeli airstrikes, and civilians who live near them can become casualties."
REHAM: (Non-English language spoken).
TANIS: She says no matter what, to expect stability in Gaza would be foolish.
REHAM: There is no guarantee for anything in Gaza. You don't know what, when and where and why the war happen.
TANIS: And when it happens, she says, no one is safe, regardless of politics.
Fatima Tanis, NPR News, Gaza City.
(SOUNDBITE OF RED HOT CHILI PEPPERS SONG, "SCAR TISSUE") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.
300x250 Ad
300x250 Ad