Public Radio for the Piedmont and High Country
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

City Council Says It Will Not Pursue Independent Investigation Into Death Of Marcus Smith

The Smith family in downtown Greensboro in 2015. From left to right: Marcus Smith, Mary Smith, George Smith, and Marcus’ brother Leonard Butler. Photo courtesy of Kim Smith.

In a surprise announcement following a closed-door meeting on Tuesday, Greensboro City Council announced it would not pursue an independent investigation into the death of Marcus Smith, or into police procedures that may have been a factor.

Activists have been calling for accountability in the death of the 38-year-old Smith, who died in police custody in 2018. Smith had been homeless and apparently experiencing a mental health crisis when officers wrestled him to the ground and used a restraint method known as “hogtying.” 

No charges have been filed despite his death being ruled a homicide, and some of those demanding justice have called him “Greensboro's George Floyd.”

The News & Record reports that following a scheduled budget discussion at Tuesday's meeting, the council met privately with the city attorney.

After that meeting, Councilwoman Michelle Kennedy read a brief statement saying that on the advice of the attorney, the city would not pursue an investigation at this time.

Kennedy said that she had originally requested an independent investigation but made no further comment.

Following the announcement, local activist Lewis Pitts said the closed session violated state open meeting laws, and fit a pattern of city government “seeking secrecy” while claiming transparency.

Smith's family filed a federal civil rights lawsuit in 2019, which remains ongoing. 

Neal Charnoff joined 88.5 WFDD as Morning Edition host in 2014. Raised in the Catskill region of upstate New York, he graduated from Sarah Lawrence College in 1983. Armed with a liberal arts degree, Neal was fully equipped to be a waiter. So he prolonged his arrested development bouncing around New York and L.A. until discovering that people enjoyed listening to his voice on the radio. After a few years doing overnight shifts at a local rock station, Neal spent most of his career at Vermont Public Radio. He began as host of a nightly jazz program, where he was proud to interview many of his idols, including Dave Brubeck and Sonny Rollins. Neal graduated to the news department, where he was the local host for NPR's All Things Considered for 14 years. In addition to news interviews and features, he originated and produced the Weekly Conversation On The Arts, as well as VPR Backstage, which profiled theater productions around the state. He contributed several stories to NPR, including coverage of a devastating ice storm. Neal now sees the value of that liberal arts degree, and approaches life with the knowledge that all subjects and all art forms are connected to each other. Neal and his wife Judy are enjoying exploring North Carolina and points south. They would both be happy to never experience a Vermont winter again.

Support quality journalism, like the story above,
with your gift right now.

Donate