Public Radio for the Piedmont and High Country
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Plaintiffs in North Carolina voter ID case want preclearance for election law changes

Both sides made closing arguments Monday in a federal court case that could decide if the state’s voter ID law continues as is.

Attorney John Freedman said the state’s photo ID requirement is part of a plan by North Carolina Republicans to consolidate their power through voter suppression targeting minorities. Freedman, representing his plaintiffs, the state NAACP, cited several cases over the last decade where GOP voting measures have been found to be unconstitutional along racial or partisan lines. 

And he offered a solution.

In his closing argument, Freedman called for North Carolina to be placed under a preclearance requirement. That’s a part of the Voting Rights Act that passed during the Civil Rights era. A section of the act required that voting laws in places with a history of voting discrimination had occurred to get a review from the federal government for proposed changes to their election laws.

North Carolina as a whole was not under preclearance, but many counties, including Guilford, were. That ended with a 2013 Supreme Court decision.

Mary Carla Babb, an attorney for the North Carolina Department of Justice, told Judge Loretta Biggs that the plaintiffs did not prove that the voter ID law had a disparate impact on minorities, as the lawsuit claims. Instead, she said, North Carolina’s law mirrors states with similar laws that were found to be constitutional. She said the judge should deny all claims. 

The photo ID requirement was in place in the November municipal elections and the March primary. David Thompson, an attorney for the legislative defendants, said in his closing argument that there were few problems despite more than 2 million votes cast.  

Paul Garber is a Winston-Salem native and an award-winning reporter who began his journalism career with an internship at The High Point Enterprise in 1993. He has previously worked at The Augusta (Ga.) Chronicle, The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, The News and Record of Greensboro and the Winston-Salem Journal, where he was the newspaper's first full-time multimedia reporter. He won the statewide Media and the Law award in 2000 and has also been recognized for his business, investigative and multimedia reporting. Paul earned a BA from Wake Forest University and has a Master's of Liberal Arts degree from Johns Hopkins University and a Master's of Journalism and Mass Communication from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. He lives in Lewisville.

Support quality journalism, like the story above,
with your gift right now.

Donate