Public Radio for the Piedmont and High Country
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

'Bathroom Bill' Fight To Continue After Judge's Ruling

Plaintiff Joaquin Carcano, center, addresses reporters after a hearing Monday, June 25, 2018, in Winston-Salem, N.C., on their lawsuit challenging the law that replaced North Carolina’s “bathroom bill.” Carcano and other transgender plaintiffs argue the new law continues to discourage transgender people from using restrooms that match their gender identity. (AP Photo/Jonathan Drew)

The legal fight over the state's controversial bathroom bill is not over.

A federal judge is allowing part of a lawsuit challenging the measure that replaced HB2 to continue.

The ruling comes more than three months after a group of plaintiffs made their case in a Winston-Salem federal courtroom as Republican legislative leaders asked for the lawsuit to be dismissed.

Among the arguments against the law was that it's discriminatory because it creates confusion over whether transgender people could be punished for using the bathroom of their choice.

Judge Thomas Schroeder rejected that point.

But he did find the plaintiffs could make a plausible argument against another part of the law - one which prohibits new anti-discrimination ordinances at the local level until 2020.

Schroeder determined that such a provision over transgender access could be found to deny them the legal protections other groups have.

The compromise bill was a bipartisan effort to stem the fallout from the original bathroom bill, known as HB2, which drew national attention and a wave of high-profile boycotts of state venues.

Paul Garber is a Winston-Salem native and an award-winning reporter who began his journalism career with an internship at The High Point Enterprise in 1993. He has previously worked at The Augusta (Ga.) Chronicle, The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, The News and Record of Greensboro and the Winston-Salem Journal, where he was the newspaper's first full-time multimedia reporter. He won the statewide Media and the Law award in 2000 and has also been recognized for his business, investigative and multimedia reporting. Paul earned a BA from Wake Forest University and has a Master's of Liberal Arts degree from Johns Hopkins University and a Master's of Journalism and Mass Communication from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. He lives in Lewisville.

Support quality journalism, like the story above,
with your gift right now.

Donate