Don't Torpedo The Dam, Full Speed Ahead For Ethiopia's Nile Project

Don't Torpedo The Dam, Full Speed Ahead For Ethiopia's Nile Project

10:06am Mar 26, 2015
The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam is under construction near Assosa, Ethiopia. When it's completed, the dam will have be able to produce 6,000 megawatts of electricity, making it the biggest hydroelectric power station in Africa.
The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam is under construction near Assosa, Ethiopia. When it's completed, the dam will have be able to produce 6,000 megawatts of electricity, making it the biggest hydroelectric power station in Africa.
Elias Asmare/AP

I once met a popular spoken word poet in Ethiopia who was asked by a government official to write a poem about the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam. (He politely explained that he didn't do poetry about infrastructure.) But it's not surprising that Ethiopia would like to inscribe this dam into the Ethiopian epic.

When completed, the Renaissance Dam promises to be the largest hydro-electric project in Africa. Funded without help from America or the West, the "renaissance" in the dam's title refers to a 70-year-old vision of Africa rising on the strength of its own abundant resources. Independence and self-reliance in the so-called "dark continent" begins with electricity.

But since Ethiopia began construction in 2011, Egypt has spun the dam as a threat. Egypt's way of life depends on the Nile River. Former president Mohammed Morsi once warned that every drop of water stolen from the Nile would be defended by a drop of Egyptian blood.

In fact, a hydropower dam doesn't steal water from downstream. It only draws power from its flow. Except during one crucial period: just after the dam is built and the reservoir is filled. A reservoir this huge will hold 63 billion cubic meters — roughly as much water as Egypt gets from the Nile over the course of a year. If the basin were to be filled too fast, Egypt's farmers would plunge into drought and its own hydropower dams would stop producing electricity.

Fear of that scenario is why Egypt's former president almost went to war with Ethiopia over the dam.

Instead, on Monday, Egypt's current president Abdel Fattah el-Sisi and Ethiopia's Prime Minister Hailemariam Desalegn signed a "Declaration of Principles" with Sudan's president as broker. Egypt approved the project and will have rights to some of the electricity that will be generated. The key negotiations to come will be over the pace of filling that giant reservoir when it's completed in the next few years. Fast enough to satisfy Ethiopia's grand ambitions but slow enough not to hobble Egypt's economy.

Aaron Wolf, a professor of geography and trained mediator who runs the Program in Water Conflict Management and Transformation at Oregon State University, says that once the reservoir is filled, the long term impact of the Renaissance Dam will be less to Egypt than to traditional Ethiopian tribes who will lose access to the river they depend upon for fishing or mining.

"Like all big dams, there are going to be impacts," he says. "But if all things were equal, you do want [to build] your dams upstream."

Negotiators for both sides will have to overcome centuries of conflict and distrust. Ethiopia rightly complains that colonial-era water treaties gave Egypt a virtual monopoly over Nile waters. Geography has also played its role. Wolf notes that "downstream" countries like Egypt tend to develop first, because that's where the flat plains and agricultural land is, while upstream countries like Ethiopia are generally more hilly and later to develop. Then when those upstream countries develop, they have a downstream impact. "That chronology is fairly common," Wolf says, from water conflicts in China, to Tajikistan, to Laos.

Even more common, of course, is the distrust that accompanies all water disputes. "I grew up in San Francisco and I grew up resenting Southern California for their incessant water needs," Wolf says. "But the corollary to that is that water also brings people into a room who wouldn't normally sit in a room together. So it brings Arabs and Israelis together, Egyptians and Ethiopians, Northern California and Southern California."

When it comes to water, even the bitterest rivals eventually end up having to take up arms or negotiate. Two powerful African economies, Egypt and Ethiopia, have moved a step toward the latter.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

We're also tracking an African conflict over water that led to the threat of war. That threat has receded for the moment along the Nile River. Both Egypt and Ethiopia rely on Nile waters. And this week, they signed an agreement allowing Ethiopia to continue building a grand hydropower dam. NPR's Gregory Warner reports.

GREGORY WARNER, BYLINE: The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam is grand in almost every way; in size, 8,500 laborers are said to be working on it night and day; in its ambition to provide cheap power to millions of Ethiopians and their neighbors. It's even grand in the Ethiopian mind. Funded without help from America or the West, the renaissance in the dam's title refers to a 70-year-old vision of Africa rising on the strength of its own abundant resources. Mammo Muchie is a professor of African innovation in Pretoria.

MAMMO MUCHIE: If you say that a renaissance means you want independence, you want freedom, one of the key things you need to have is to harness electricity.

WARNER: But to Egypt, all the way downstream, Ethiopia's dam is spun as a threat. The former Egyptian president, Mohamed Morsi, once warned that every drop of water stolen from the Nile would be defended by a drop of Egyptian blood.

MUCHIE: What Egypt has done is play a kind of Nile superpower.

WARNER: You may be wondering - a hydroelectric dam by definition doesn't steal water from downstream, it just draws power from its flow, except for this one time just after the dam is built and the reservoir needs to be filled. A reservoir this huge - 63 billion cubic meters - is roughly as much water as Egypt gets from the Nile over the course of an entire year.

AARON WOLF: The fill period is the most sensitive because that's when flow downstream really is decreased.

WARNER: Aaron Wolf runs the program in Water Conflict Management and Transformation at the University of Oregon. He says a key issue will be how fast Ethiopia fills the reservoir, fast enough to satisfy its grand ambitions, slow enough not to plunge Egyptian farmers into drought. The long-term threat, though, is less to Egypt than to Ethiopian tribes, whose traditional way of life depends on access to waterways.

WOLF: On fishing from the river, on mining from the river, and they won't have access any longer. So like all big dams, there are going to be impacts. But if all things were equal, you want your dams upstream.

WARNER: Egypt and Ethiopia have now signed a deal with Sudan as broker. It gives Egypt some dibs on the electricity that will be generated and sets up timelines for checking its impact on water levels. But the issues are far from over in part because Egypt and Ethiopia have been fighting over these Nile waters for so long. Colonial-era agreements gave Egypt a virtual monopoly on the waters, and as with all water conflicts, there's a long history of distrust.

WOLF: Now, I grew up in San Francisco, and I grew up resenting Southern California for their incessant water needs. The corollary to that is water also brings people into a room who wouldn't normally sit in a room together. So it brings Arabs and Israelis together, Egyptians and Ethiopians, Northern California and Southern California.

WARNER: He says when it comes to water, even the bitterest rivals end up eventually having to negotiate. Gregory Warner, NPR News, Nairobi. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Support your
public radio station