Can You Spot The Fake Fragonard?

Can You Spot The Fake Fragonard?

10:26am May 02, 2015
A visitor views a replica of Jean-Honore Fragonard's 18th century painting, Young Woman (right) as the original hangs to its left.
A visitor views a replica of Jean-Honore Fragonard's 18th century painting, Young Woman (right) as the original hangs to its left.
Carl Court / Getty Images

I'm not sure a picture is worth a thousand words. But why do some pictures sell for millions and others that seem identical go for just a few dollars?

Since February, the Dulwich Picture Gallery in south London has hung a fake among its permanent collection of 270 Old Masters. Maybe we should call it a "tribute" Old Master: a hand-painted, unapologetic stroke-for-stroke copy of a great painting, produced at the Meishing Oil Painting Manufacture Company, one of many art factories in China, where hundreds of artists — and given their technical skills, that word seems earned — make exact, oil-painted copies of Monets, Matisses, Picassos and other masterpieces.

The gallery invited visitors to detect the knockoff appearing among masterpieces. Nearly 3,000 people cast votes; only 347 guessed correctly that the replica Old Master was an imitation Jean-Honoré Fragonard painting, Young Woman, an 18th century portrait of a young woman who has dark brown hair, tied loosely, and kind brown eyes.

Xavier Bray, the gallery's chief curator, says the idea wasn't to try to get gallery-goers to play international art detective, or to just fan out to find the Canalettos, Gainsboroughs and Rembrandts, but to look deeply and intently at every painting on their walls.

"Never before have I seen so many people actively looking at each painting," he said. "The visual exercise of comparing and contrasting will demonstrate how exciting it is to engage with an original work of art."

The last time a Fragonard came up for auction, it sold for $28 million. This replica Fragonard was painted to order in China and sold for a little over $100.

Try to buy even a good pair of shoes for that price.

But does imitating an original so cheaply make the original seem less valuable?

I was prepared to be outraged when I logged into the websites of a few of the Chinese art factories. Instead, I came close to ordering replicas of Hopper's Nighthawks and Caillebotte's Paris: A Rainy Day; because I love looking deeply into both paintings, and art prints can look flat. I imagined what it would be like to hang a Seurat over our cat's food bowl, and tell visitors, "She thinks Renoir painted too many dogs."

The replica could even be a reminder: that real originality — I won't try to stretch the word genius — isn't only the skills to paint, with color, words, or notes, but to see something no one else does; and help it come alive.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

SCOTT SIMON, HOST:

I'm not sure a picture is worth a thousand words. But why do some pictures sell for millions and others that seem identical go for just a few dollars? Since February, the Dulwich Picture Gallery in South London has hung a fake among its permanent collection of 270 Old Masters. Maybe we should call it a tribute Old Master - a hand-painted, unapologetic, stroke-for-stroke copy of a great painting, produced at the Meishing Oil Painting Manufacture Company - one of many art factories in China where hundreds of artists have given their technical skills - that words seems earned - make exact oil-painted copies of Monets, Matisses, Picassos and other masterpieces. The Gallery invited visitors to detect the knock-off appearing among masterpieces. Nearly 3,000 people cast votes - only 347 guessed correctly. The replica Old Master was an imitation Jean-Honore Fragonard painting, "Young Woman," an 18th century portrait of a young woman who has dark brown hair tied loosely and kind brown eyes.

Dr. Xavier Bray, the gallery's chief curator, says the idea wasn't to try to get gallery goers to play international art detective but to look deeply and intently at every painting on their walls - not just fan out to find the Canalettos, Gainsboroughs, and Rembrandts. "Never before have I seen so many people actively looking at each painting," he said. "The visual exercise of comparing and contrasting will demonstrate how exciting it is to engage with an original work of art."

The last time a Fragonard came up for action, it sold for $28 million. This replica Fragonard was painted-to-order in China and sold for a little over a $100. Try to buy even a good pair of shoes for that price. But does imitating an original so cheaply make the original seem less valuable? I was prepared to be outraged when I logged into the websites of a few of the Chinese art factories. Instead, I came close to ordering replicas of Hopper's "Nighthawks" and Caillebotte's "Paris: A Rainy Day" because I love looking deeply into both paintings and art prints can look flat. I imagine what it would be like to hang a Seurat over our cat's food bowl and tell visitors, "she thinks Renoir painted too many dogs." The replica could even be a reminder that real originality - I won't try to stretch the word genius - isn't only the skills to paint with color, words or notes, but to see something no one else does, and help it come alive. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Support your
public radio station