Last Armenian Village In Turkey Keeps Silent About 1915 Slaughter

Last Armenian Village In Turkey Keeps Silent About 1915 Slaughter

11:45am Apr 22, 2015
Armenian refugees on the deck of the French cruiser that rescued them in 1915 during the massacre of the Armenian populations in the Ottoman Empire. The photo does not specify precisely where the refugees were from. However, residents of Vakifli, the last
Armenian refugees on the deck of the French cruiser that rescued them in 1915 during the massacre of the Armenian populations in the Ottoman Empire. The photo does not specify precisely where the refugees were from. However, residents of Vakifli, the last
Photo 12 / Photo12/UIG/Getty Images
  • Armenian refugees on the deck of the French cruiser that rescued them in 1915 during the massacre of the Armenian populations in the Ottoman Empire. The photo does not specify precisely where the refugees were from. However, residents of Vakifli, the last

    Armenian refugees on the deck of the French cruiser that rescued them in 1915 during the massacre of the Armenian populations in the Ottoman Empire. The photo does not specify precisely where the refugees were from. However, residents of Vakifli, the last

    Photo 12 / Photo12/UIG/Getty Images

  • Cem Capar is one of the leaders in Vakifli, the last Armenian village in Turkey. Armenians worldwide are speaking out about the slaughter of some 1.5 million of their ancestors 100 years ago. But in Vakifli, which has just 135 residents, Capar and others

    Cem Capar is one of the leaders in Vakifli, the last Armenian village in Turkey. Armenians worldwide are speaking out about the slaughter of some 1.5 million of their ancestors 100 years ago. But in Vakifli, which has just 135 residents, Capar and others

    Deborah Amos / NPR

  • An Armenian protester holds a sign reading "1915 never again" during a demonstration near the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France, on Jan. 28.

    An Armenian protester holds a sign reading "1915 never again" during a demonstration near the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France, on Jan. 28.

    Vincent Kessler / Reuters /Landov

A hundred years ago this week, the Ottoman Empire began the killings and forced marches of Armenians in what most historians call the first genocide of the 20th century.

Turkey staunchly denies that label, saying the deaths — estimated by historians at around 1.5 million — were part of widespread ethnic fighting in a civil war.

Regardless of the label used, the result was destruction of virtually every Armenian community in the Ottoman Empire, which collapsed after the war. What was left of the country transitioned into the modern-day Republic of Turkey.

Today, Vakifli, in central southern Turkey near the border with Syria, is the only Armenian village that remains. Residents there are still hesitant to raise the past.

The village — perched on a mountainside, with fragrant fruit trees, clear air, and stunning views of the Mediterranean Sea that are a draw for tourists — survived the massacres and forced marches with courage and luck a century ago.

But now, the village is facing another battle for survival. Most young people have fled the village for better opportunities in cities. The population has dwindled to 135 mostly elderly residents.

Silence is the survival strategy. Even as others mark the anniversary of their tragic history, the Armenians of Vakifli remain wary of public ceremonies here, fearing a Turkish backlash.

Cem Capar, chairman of the Foundation of the Vakifli Surp Asdvadzadzin Church, sums it up this way: "People come and ask, 'What are your ideas about the Armenian genocide?' And I say, 'I don't want to think about that.' "

Cem Capar is one of the leaders in Vakifli, the last Armenian village in Turkey. Armenians worldwide are speaking out about the slaughter of some 1.5 million of their ancestors 100 years ago. But in Vakifli, which has just 135 residents, Capar and others decline to discuss the matter.

Cem Capar is one of the leaders in Vakifli, the last Armenian village in Turkey. Armenians worldwide are speaking out about the slaughter of some 1.5 million of their ancestors 100 years ago. But in Vakifli, which has just 135 residents, Capar and others decline to discuss the matter.

Deborah Amos / NPR

On a walk from the church along the cobbled streets of the village, he stops to emphasize his point about the upcoming commemorations.

Politicians are exploiting Armenians' history, Capar insists: "They are hurting us, and that's why I don't want to talk about it."

Richard Hovannisian says the residents of Vakifli are inherently cautious when speaking to outsiders. Hovannisian was born into an Armenian family that escaped the massacres; he's now a scholar of Armenian history at UCLA.

"It's very touchy being an Armenian in Turkey," he says. The elderly residents of Vakifli have concluded that "any commemoration would not be good for them."

But Vakifli's history is dramatic. Residents fought against the Ottoman onslaught in a story that later was recounted in a novel, The Forty Days Of Musa Dagh, which was followed by a movie.

Vakifli residents, along with those in surrounding villages, headed up Moses Mountain, or Musa Dagh, and held out until a passing French warship spotted the banner they had hoisted: "Christians in distress: Rescue."

The French warship evacuated more than 5,000 Armenians. They only returned after the war when the area came under Syrian control. When the province became part of the Turkish Republic in 1939, many Armenians fled again. Only the villagers of Vakifli stayed on and eventually became Turkish citizens.

"Turkey is my country; yes, I'm an Armenian who lives in Turkey," says Capar.

An Armenian protester holds a sign reading

An Armenian protester holds a sign reading "1915 never again" during a demonstration near the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France, on Jan. 28.

Vincent Kessler/Reuters /Landov

In the runup to the centennial, Turkey's official position has only hardened. Turkey's President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has become more combative, challenging the pope and European governments that have called the events of 1915 a genocide.

The controversy tests Capar's identity as an Armenian and as a Turk. To an outsider, he appears to defend Turkey's position.

"Any attack that happens to Turkey, I take it as an attack on myself," he tells a group of journalists who have come for a visit to Vakifli.

Hovannisian, who has often visited Vakifli, says the residents "don't want to be regarded as disloyal."

Identity is a complicated matter. Everyone in Vakifli is proud to be descendants of Armenians who resisted the brutal Ottoman campaign. Mayor Berc Kartun asks if I've seen the movie about Vakifli's history — but also points out that Vakifli's survival now depends on the generosity of the Turkish government.

"We cannot deny that our government is helping us a lot," he says.

The restoration of the Armenian church, repairs to the roads, and an organic farming plan are all government programs. There is enough economic opportunity to keep his son, Haroot, 28, from going elsewhere.

But his generation feels the acute shadow of history

"We are a small village — we are a minority here," Haroot says. "That is why I feel the same pressure, the same as my father."

Residents say the Turkish government now protects Christians, offering refuge to neighboring Syrian Christians fleeing Islamist radicals, including some who have been sheltered in Vakifli. Still, the 100-year-old history, Vakifli's legacy, will not be commemorated here.

"It is an old-age rest home," says Hovannisian. There is not even a school in the village, he says — the kids have to be bused outside for education.

It's part of the Turkish policy to disperse Armenians in the province, he adds. So, in the long shadow of history, the Armenians in the last remaining village in Turkey have to wonder how long they can keep their heritage alive.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

A notorious chapter in history began 100 years ago this week, the massacres and forced marches of Armenians in the waning days of the Ottoman Empire. Up to 1.5 million Armenians died in what most historians call the first genocide of the last century. Turkey denies that label, saying the deaths were part of widespread ethnic fighting in a civil war. About 60,000 Armenians still live in Turkey. NPR's Deborah Amos visited some who are not eager to bring up the past.

(SOUNDBITE OF CHICKENS SQUAWKING)

DEBORAH AMOS, BYLINE: This is the last Armenian village in Turkey. One hundred years ago, Vakifli survived the devastating massacres with courage and luck. Now the village is a draw for tourists, perched on a mountainside with fragrant fruit orchards and stunning views of the Mediterranean Sea. But Vakifli is facing a different battle for survival. The young people leave for jobs someplace else. Only 135 residents remain, mostly elderly. Silence is their survival strategy. The Armenians of Vakifli remain wary of any public ceremonies. They fear stirring a Turkish backlash, says village leader Cem Capar.

CEM CAPAR: (Through interpreter) People come and ask, what are your ideas about the Armenian genocide? And I say, I don't want to think about that.

AMOS: Why don't you want to think about it?

CAPAR: (Through interpreter) Politicians are exploiting it. They're hurting us. And that's why I don't want to talk about it.

AMOS: But the history of Vakifli and neighboring villages is famous. The movie "Forty Days of Musa Dagh" recounts resistance here. Armenians held out until they were rescued by a passing French warship. The villagers of Vakifli returned and eventually became Turkish citizens. At the local church, Capar tells me, Turkey is my country.

CAPAR: (Foreign language spoken).

AMOS: But his country's official denial has only hardened, opening Turkey to international censure. It's a conflict for an Armenian. But to an outsider, Capar speaks as a Turk.

CAPAR: (Through interpreter) Any attack that happens to Turkey, I take it as an attack on myself.

MAYOR BERC KARTUN: (Foreign language spoken).

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN: (Foreign language spoken).

AMOS: Identity is a complicated matter. Everyone here is proud to be descendants of the Armenians who resisted, no one more so than the mayor, Berc Kartun. When we visit him at home, he explains Vakifli's survival is now dependent on the Turkish government.

B. KARTUN: (Through interpreter) We cannot deny that our government is helping us a lot.

AMOS: The church's restoration, repairs to roads, an organic farming plan - all government-supported projects. It's enough economic activity to keep Kartun's son, Haroot, from looking for opportunities outside Vakifli.

Do you feel this history in the same way that your father does?

HAROOT KARTUN: (Foreign language spoken).

AMOS: "I'm 28. I'm young. Of course I feel it as my father does," he says. They say the Turkish government now protects Christians, a refuge for neighboring Syrian Christians fleeing Islamist radicals. Still, Vakifli's history won't be publicly commemorated.

H. KARTUN: (Through interpreter) We are a small village. We are a minority here, and that's why I feel the same pressure, the same as my father.

AMOS: And these Armenian Turks wonder how long they can keep their heritage alive. Deborah Amos, NPR News, Vakifli. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Support your
public radio station