In Havana, A Journey Into The Forbidden With A Provocative Artist

In Havana, A Journey Into The Forbidden With A Provocative Artist

8:00pm Mar 25, 2015
Cuban artist Tania Bruguera poses for a photograph near the statue of José Martí in Havana's Revolution Plaza. She was arrested in December for planning a political performance there.
Cuban artist Tania Bruguera poses for a photograph near the statue of José Martí in Havana's Revolution Plaza. She was arrested in December for planning a political performance there.
Eyder Peralta / NPR
  • Cuban artist Tania Bruguera poses for a photograph near the statue of José Martí in Havana's Revolution Plaza. She was arrested in December for planning a political performance there.

    Cuban artist Tania Bruguera poses for a photograph near the statue of José Martí in Havana's Revolution Plaza. She was arrested in December for planning a political performance there.

    Eyder Peralta / NPR

  • A image of Ernesto "Che" Guevara overlooks the plaza. The building houses Cuba's Ministry of the Interior.

    A image of Ernesto "Che" Guevara overlooks the plaza. The building houses Cuba's Ministry of the Interior.

    Eyder Peralta / NPR

  • La Plaza de la Revolucion,  Havana's version of Moscow's Red Square or Beijing's Tiananmen Square, as the sun rises over the city.

    La Plaza de la Revolucion, Havana's version of Moscow's Red Square or Beijing's Tiananmen Square, as the sun rises over the city.

    Eyder Peralta / NPR

It was still dark when Tania Bruguera hopped into a cab with us on her way to Revolution Square.

"All of a sudden it looks quite subversive what we're doing," she said. Her voice revealed a little nervousness, but it translated into a giddy laughter.

The last time Bruguera planned a trip like this, Cuban security agents hauled her out of her mother's apartment and put her in jail. But two months later, here she was in a cab with some NPR journalists, navigating the desolate, pre-dawn streets of Havana.

Bruguera is a provocative Cuban performance artist. In December, right after President Obama and Cuban President Raúl Castro announced their diplomatic breakthrough, she flew down to Havana from New York City, where she has lived in recent years.

After some futile talks to get permission from Cuban officialdom, she announced that she would stage a performance piece at the square, a sacred place for the regime.

She invited Cubans to come speak freely into a microphone for one minute about life on the island. It was the first real test of just how tolerant the country had become of dissident voices. Some dissidents showed up and security forces arrested more than 30 of them. The event never happened.

Bruguera was detained before she could even get to the square, and her Cuban passport was taken. In the months since, she has been jailed twice and interrogated several times.

Now, looking out the cab window, we could see lights in the tall buildings of Havana starting to come on. We could see the sidewalks and the pavement bathed in the yellow hue of the street lights.

The afternoon before, we had met with Bruguera for an interview and asked what she thought would happen if she tried to visit the square again.

"I don't know what would happen," she said. "I think I would not be allowed to arrive there."

Then, she smiled mischievously and asked, "Do you want to try it?"


Trouble is not new for Bruguera. Her performances have often been described as outrageous. Perhaps the best example of that happened during the Venice Biennale in 2009.

As part of a performance exploring the sacrifices political artists have to make, she loaded a gun with a single bullet and played Russian roulette on stage. Her audience was stunned and stepped in to stop her.

A image of Ernesto

A image of Ernesto "Che" Guevara overlooks the plaza. The building houses Cuba's Ministry of the Interior.

Eyder Peralta/NPR

"I was lucky, I guess," Bruguera said. "My work in general, and I think art in general, is the space you have in society to push the boundaries of behavior, of social conduct and also politics."

She added: "I think artists can use themselves in performance to say what other people will not dare to do or to say."

Bruguera, 46, was born in Havana. Her father was a man who believed in the revolution and worked for the Castro regime as a diplomat.

In the '90s, Bruguera caused her father and the regime heartache when she printed her own newspaper — a serious crime in Cuba. And in 2009 for the Havana Art Biennial, she staged a performance she called Taitlin's Whisper #6.

A podium was flanked by two people dressed as soldiers. As each Cuban said his or her piece, one of the costumed soldiers placed a white dove on the speaker's shoulder. One of the speakers was popular blogger Yoani Sanchez, whom the government considers a dissident. During her one-minute speech, Sanchez said that "the time has come to jump over the wall of control."

The Cuban government was not impressed.

The Biennial organizing committee called Bruguera's work "an anti-cultural event of shameful opportunism that offends Cuban artists and foreigners who came to offer their work and solidarity."

By planning a similar performance for Havana's Revolution Square in December, Bruguera was courting trouble. And she found it.


La Plaza de la Revolucíon is Havana's Red Square, its Tiananmen Square. It's a vast open space beside the seashore. It's known as a place for mass, government-organized rallies.

When we arrived at the square, Bruguera noted how beautiful it is and also how imposing it seemed. On one side is a monumental statue of Cuba's independence hero, José Martí. On the other side, in the distance, are buildings for the ministries of defense and interior with outline portraits of Ernesto "Che" Guevara and Camilo Cienfuegos, two of the country's bearded revolutionary heroes.

La Plaza de la Revolucion,  Havana's version of Moscow's Red Square or Beijing's Tiananmen Square, as the sun rises over the city.

La Plaza de la Revolucion, Havana's version of Moscow's Red Square or Beijing's Tiananmen Square, as the sun rises over the city.

Eyder Peralta /NPR

Bruguera said that since her aborted performance, the Cuban government has tried to intimidate her. The prosecutor handling her case checks in with her a few times a week, she said, and the block leader makes sure she knows that they are watching her at all moments. For the first few weeks following her performance, state security vehicles parked outside her place in Havana. And she said that in an effort to alienate her, the state has tried to intimidate her friends.

"Three months ago, I would have thought somebody saying all this was crazy," Bruguera said. "The biggest damage they have done to me is now I have doubts about the revolution that I didn't have three months ago."

By the time we got to the foot of the statue of José Martí, Bruguera seemed more at ease. She said that all she intended to do here last December was put a microphone right here, in this symbolic square.

"The idea was to invert the dynamic," she said. "Because we are always here looking up to the leaders of the revolution and hearing [them speak into] their own microphones. I wanted to revert that dynamic and have the microphone in the street, in the place where normally you would walk, passively or shouting some chants that you learned."

She said she wanted to shake Cubans of their "automatic responses," their "learned responses" and "give people the freedom to say whatever they want."

As we talked, the sky began to turn orange and the stars began to fade into the light. In a space like this and talking to a person like Bruguera, the line between art and politics seemed blurred.

"Good politicians know how to give new meanings to everything," she said. "And the Cuban revolution has been a very good example, almost a case study of that. Fidel was really brilliant at changing the meanings of things, and that's what an artist does — an artist rethinks the meaning of things."

In choosing this hallowed, political ground for her performance, Bruguera said that she wanted to "give art a space in the history of the country."

All of that, obviously, didn't happen. Instead, Bruguera's future is now a huge question mark. The government has yet to decide whether she will charged and tried for what they hold was an attempt at inciting a public disturbance. And Bruguera's passport is still in their hands. The day before, Bruguera told us that these days she feels like she is re-enacting her Russian roulette piece — this time taking her chances with Cuban authorities.

By the time we wrapped up our interview, we were no longer under the cover of night. Bruguera was standing at Revolution Square in broad daylight.

A lone police officer was now keeping watch, and as we made our way back to the taxi, Bruguera greeted him.

"Buenos dias," she said. He just nodded.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Audie Cornish.

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

And I'm Robert Siegel, reporting this week on my trip to Havana earlier this month. Today, an artist on the edge - Tania Bruguera is a provocative 46-year-old Cuban performance artist who's in trouble with Cuban authorities. In December, right after President Obama and Cuban President Raul Castro announced their diplomatic breakthrough, Bruguera flew down to Havana from New York City where she's lived in recent years. After some futile talks with Cuban officialdom, she announced that she would stage a performance piece in Havana's Revolution Square. She invited Cubans to come speak freely into a microphone for one minute about life in Cuba. On this program, she told NPR's Lourdes Garcia-Navarro about her plan.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED BROADCAST)

TANIA BRUGUERA: It's just to tell people in the street, come, and share with us your doubts, your happiness - whatever you think right now about what is happening in Cuba, and what is the idea of Cuba that you want.

SIEGEL: A few people turned out, but not Tania Bruguera. She never made it because she was detained, and in the months since, she has been jailed twice and interrogated several times. This was not the first time that she challenged the rules in Cuba. Tonia Bruguera set up her open mic at the 2009 Havana Biennial Arts Festival at an art center in the old, restored part of the city. Some came to speak. This woman came to cry. The recording is from

Bruguera's website. A podium was flanked by two people dressed as soldiers, and as each Cuban said his or her piece, one of the costumed soldiers placed a white dove on the speaker's shoulder.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

YOANI SANCHEZ: (Speaking Spanish).

SIEGEL: This speaker, the popular blogger Yoani Sanchez, said, "The time has come to jump over the wall of control."

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

SANCHEZ: (Speaking Spanish).

(APPLAUSE)

SIEGEL: Cuban authorities did not applaud. The Biennial organizing committee called Bruguera's work an anti-cultural event of shameful opportunism that offends Cuban artists and foreigners who came to offer their work and solidarity.

By planning the same performance for Havana's Revolution Square in December, Bruguera was courting trouble, and she found it. She is at large, but her passport has been seized so that she can't travel to New York or to Chicago where she studied and taught art. A couple of weeks ago, I met Tania Bruguera in Havana, and we talked about the politics of art and the art of politics.

I want you to convey some sense of the breadth of performance art that you have done because some of it is - it doesn't just sound outrageous, I think it is outrageous.

BRUGUERA: (Laughter).

SIEGEL: The Russian roulette performance.

BRUGUERA: Yeah.

SIEGEL: So you, before an audience and with a text, actually had a gun...

BRUGUERA: A gun, yeah.

SIEGEL: ...With one bullet.

BRUGUERA: Yeah, one bullet. Yeah. And I actually play Russian roulette. I was lucky (laughter) I guess. No, but I think what my work in general - and I think art in general - is this space you have in society to push - let's say push the boundaries of behavior, social conduct and also politics. In the case of the Russian roulette that you ask, I was using that as a metaphor because I was reading a text I wrote about the sacrifice political artist has to do.

SIEGEL: Where's the line between performance art that is uniquely expressive and a narcissism that is all about the individual artist and not about anything beyond her?

BRUGUERA: Yeah. Yeah. I think artists can use themselves in performance to say what other people will not dare to do or to say and putting themselves in risk.

SIEGEL: And so far as you can tell, there isn't some loosening of these constraints now - there's not some liberalization that accompanies the rounds of talks with the U.S.

BRUGUERA: I think that they accuse me to not want the United States and Cuba to have relation, but that's completely false. What I want is for us to not only receive from the United State their products and their material goods, but to receive from them an exchange on freedom of expression and history of tolerance to people who think different.

SIEGEL: You're still going to play Russian roulette with this, even so?

BRUGUERA: I'm going to keep rolling - como se - rolling the - keep rolling the chamber of the gun.

SIEGEL: This was more than two months after her arrest. Had she been to Revolution Square since then?

BRUGUERA: I haven't gone after that. Maybe one day ago. But I don't know. I don't know what - I think I will not be allowed to arrive there or as soon as I get there, they want to take me out of there.

SIEGEL: The next morning, we went together to the scene of her alleged unconsummated crime of last December - not for a performance, but for another interview.

Thanks to daylight savings...

BRUGUERA: Si.

SIEGEL: ...We're in the dark.

(LAUGHTER)

SIEGEL: It was so early in the morning, the sun wasn't up.

BRUGUERA: All of the sudden it looks quite subversive, what we're doing. (Laughter).

SIEGEL: Because it's dark.

BRUGUERA: It's dark. (Laughter).

SIEGEL: The square, La Plaza de la Revolucion, is Havana's red square - its Tiananmen Square. It is a vast, open space beside the seashore. It's a place for mass pro-government rallies. We stood just below a monumental statue of Cuba's independence hero, Jose Marti. In the distance are the ministries of defense and interior with outline portraits of revolutionary heroes that are several stories high.

You would have had a microphone set up somewhere around here?

BRUGUERA: Yeah. The idea was to have a microphone, and the idea was to invert the dynamic because we are always here looking up to the leaders of the revolution and hear them in their own microphone. And I wanted to revert that dynamic and have the microphone in the street in the place where normally you would walk passively or shouting some chants that you learn and go out of this kind of automatic responses and learned responses and give people the freedom to say whatever they want. They could talk about the school, the professor of their kids - whatever - the neighbor, bad behavior - whatever they wanted. I didn't have an agenda.

SIEGEL: You know, Tania, I find this very interesting. You speak about the political act, which this was - which you had planned, as an act of artistic performance. I mean I don't - (laughter) where do art and politics - where's the line between the two of them?

BRUGUERA: Well, I think that good politicians know how to give new meanings to everything, and Cuban revolution has been a very, very good example - almost a case study. I mean, Fidel was really brilliant at changing the meaning of things, and that's what an artist does. An artist rethink the meaning of things. And as a performance artist, I can say that his 6, 7, 10-hour speeches are the longest performances I've seen in Havana - in Cuba. Yeah, I think art and politics are extremely linked. They share some of the same goals and the same resources, and that's what I'm advocating - you know, to give art a space in the history of a country.

SIEGEL: Well, you never got to set up your microphone, but you got to speak into our microphones in Revolution Square.

BRUGUERA: Yes, thank you for that opportunity.

SIEGEL: Tania Bruguera, Cuban performance artist in Havana earlier this month. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Support your
public radio station