Drones Increase Heart Rates Of Wild Bears. Too Much Stress?

Drones Increase Heart Rates Of Wild Bears. Too Much Stress?

12:52pm Aug 14, 2015
A brown bear in its natural habitat. Wildlife ecologists in Minnesota found that black bears in their study experienced an increase in heart rate when buzzed by drones.
A brown bear in its natural habitat. Wildlife ecologists in Minnesota found that black bears in their study experienced an increase in heart rate when buzzed by drones.
iStockphoto

For wildlife biologists, unmanned aerial vehicles are like a dream come true.

Instead of struggling through rugged, difficult terrain to get to the animal they want to study, they can just send in a drone with a camera.

And as drones get cheaper and more available, everyone in biology seems to have new ideas for how to use them, says Mark Ditmer, a wildlife ecologist at the University of Minnesota, St. Paul.

But how do the animals feel about these little UFOs hovering overhead?

That's what Ditmer wanted to know. He wondered how drones could change an animal's life: "What's the effect on the individual when we have this drone flying in close and kind of watching them?"

Ditmer realized he could explore this question by flying drones over some black bears in Minnesota that were already being monitored for a different study.

The details of what he discovered — that the drones significantly changed the heart rates of the bears — were just published in the journal Current Biology.

For the original study, bears were outfitted with both GPS locaters and small implanted heart sensors "that record every heartbeat continuously throughout the year," Ditmer says.

The cardiac monitors were developed for humans, but they're in the bears as part of an effort to understand how bears manage to hibernate through the winter — and then resume their normal activity with no problems. Figuring that out might someday help prevent muscle loss in people who are bedridden for long periods.

To do the study on drones, all Ditmer's team had to do was get some small, off-the-shelf flying helicopters and program them to make short flights over the monitored bears.

"They sounded a little bit like flying weed wackers," Ditmer says.

They managed to conduct 18 flights over four bears. And what they found is that a visit from a drone made a bear's heart beat faster.

"One of them was a 400 percent increase from about 41 beats per minute to over 160 beats per minute," Ditmer says.

This happened even though video taken by the drones showed the bears acting blase.

"We need to be aware that just because we can't visually see an effect, that it doesn't mean there's not some sort of stress response going on," Ditmer says.

One bear foraging in a cornfield did run away for, maybe, 15 feet but then stopped, says Ditmer, "and watched the drone circle overhead."

The study has left Ditmer with a lot of questions.

"We don't know if bears or other species can habituate to having drones flying over them," he says. "Right now, it's just getting started — but I guarantee you in five to 10 years it will just be commonplace to be using them for many aspects of research and conservation."

So far, there's been hardly any research into how wild birds and animals react to drones.

One study published earlier this year explored how birds responded to drones flying overhead. But it looked just at behaviors like flying or swimming away, and not physiological responses that might reveal stress.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

Wildlife biologists have become big fans of unmanned aerial vehicles, commonly known as drones. Instead of struggling through rugged terrain to get the animal they want to study, they can just send in a drone with a camera. Of course, it's not known exactly how animals feel about drones. NPR's Nell Greenfieldboyce reports that scientists recently set out to answer that question.

NELL GREENFIELDBOYCE, BYLINE: Mark Ditmer is a wildlife ecologist at the University of Minnesota in St. Paul. He says as drones get cheaper and more available, everyone in biology seems to have new ideas for how to use them. For example, one of his colleagues wanted to fly drones over a big marsh to locate the nests of sandhill cranes.

MARK DITMER: And it makes his life so much easier if he can not have to go on foot through thick vegetation to find these things.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: But Ditmer is more interested in how drones could affect the animal's life.

DITMER: What's the effect on the individual when we have this drone, you know, flying in close and kind of watching them?

GREENFIELDBOYCE: He realized he could explore this by flying drones over some black bears in Minnesota that were already being monitored for a different study. These bears were outfitted with both GPS locators and small implanted heart sensors...

DITMER: ...That record every heartbeat continuously throughout the year.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: So his team got ahold of small, off-the-shelf flying helicopters.

DITMER: They sounded a little bit like flying weed wackers.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: And programmed them to make short flights over the bears. They managed to do 18 flights over four bears, and what they found is that a visit from a drone made a bear's heart beat faster.

DITMER: One of them was a 400 percent increase from about 41 beats per minute to over 160 beats per minute.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: This happened even though video taken by the drones showed the bears acting blase.

DITMER: We need to be aware that just because we can't, you know, visually see an effect, that it doesn't mean that there's not some sort of stress response going on.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: Ditmer says one bear, foraging in a cornfield, did run away for maybe 15 feet, but then stopped...

DITMER: ...And watched the drone circle overhead.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: This study appears in the journal Current Biology, and it's left Ditmer with a lot of questions.

DITMER: We don't know if bears or other species can habituate to having drones flying over them.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: He says that's really important to know.

DITMER: Right now it's, you know, just getting started, but I guarantee you in 5 to 10 years, it'll just be commonplace to be using them for many aspects of research and conservation.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: But so far, there's been hardly any research into how wild animals react to drones. Nell Greenfieldboyce, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Support your
public radio station