Cancer Spawns A Construction Boom In Cleveland

Cancer Spawns A Construction Boom In Cleveland

5:08pm May 11, 2015
An architectural rendering of the Cleveland Clinic's planned cancer center.
An architectural rendering of the Cleveland Clinic's planned cancer center.
Courtesy of the Cleveland Clinic
  • An architectural rendering of the Cleveland Clinic's planned cancer center.

    An architectural rendering of the Cleveland Clinic's planned cancer center.

    Courtesy of the Cleveland Clinic

  • Cliff Kazmierczak of Turner Construction oversees the building of the Cleveland Clinic's new cancer outpatient center.

    Cliff Kazmierczak of Turner Construction oversees the building of the Cleveland Clinic's new cancer outpatient center.

    Sarah Jane Tribble/WCPN

It's difficult to imagine that a seven-story glass building will soon take the place of what's now a vast hole near the corner of Carnegie Avenue and 105th Street in Cleveland. But Cliff Kazmierczak, who is with Turner Construction and overseeing the transformation, points to the gray sky, tracing a silhouette with his fingertips. In two years, he says, the Cleveland Clinic's nearly $300 million cancer center is slated to open here.

Cliff Kazmierczak of Turner Construction oversees the building of the Cleveland Clinic's new cancer outpatient center.

Cliff Kazmierczak of Turner Construction oversees the building of the Cleveland Clinic's new cancer outpatient center.

Sarah Jane Tribble/WCPN

"The big thing is to make the patient comfortable with the treatments that they're going through," he says of the building's design. "So lighting, light colors, [and] as much natural light as possible are always very important to cancer patients."

Kazmierczak came to this project after overseeing construction of the cancer hospital at Ohio State University a few hours south of here. All around the U.S., the health care industry is building up to take care of an expected influx of cancer patients.

The Advisory Board Company, a firm that does health care consulting, works with hospitals and doctors. Last year it found that about 25 percent of its members that have oncology departments were either constructing a cancer center or had built one in the past three years. The Advisory Board's Deirdre Fuller says people are more likely to get cancer as they get older.

"Now that everyone is looking forward and seeing the aging of the baby boomers," she says, "it's certainly adding some fuel to that fire."

And most boomers will get health insurance through Medicare — which is a steady paycheck for hospitals.

Dr. Brian Bolwell heads the Cleveland Clinic's cancer institute. He says hospitals have to meet the need.

"In the past five years, volumes go up, depending on location, between 5 and 10 percent a year," Bolwell says. "And there's no end in sight to that volume of growth."

The Cleveland Clinic, along with its local competitor, University Hospitals, treat about 70 percent of the region's cancer patients. And when the Cleveland Clinic opens its new center, the two will be located within a five-minute drive of each other.

Historically, state governments have required hospitals to meet a certificate of need before building a hospital. But beginning in the late 1980s, states across the country began deregulating. Ohio's certificate of need requirements for hospitals ended in the late 1990s, though it still requires it for long-term care facilities.

Dr. Nathan Levitan, who heads the cancer center at University Hospitals, doesn't seem worried about the competition. His 4-year-old hospital, he says, is mostly full every day.

"We discharged over 11,000 patients with cancer in 2014," Levitan says, "which is about a 20 percent increase over just a few years beforehand."

He says that's because both hospitals employ and contract with thousands of doctors. And in the world of cancer care, doctors have a lot of influence.

People usually don't shop for cancer treatment until they are diagnosed, and at that moment their doctor's advice on where to go matters a lot.

Bill Ryan leads a hospital advocacy group in Cleveland. He says that with so many expected patients, building is good for a hospital's bottom line, and good for patients.

"If you can run enough procedures through a facility, you're going to get some economies of scale that will generate [a profit] margin," he says. "The other thing you get when you run enough procedures through a facility, is a level of expertise that improves the quality of care that the individual gets."

And when talking about the future of cancer care, hospital leaders tend to talk about quality. They insist that focusing on the quality of care for patients will eventually lower the cost to patients, too.

This story is part of a reporting partnership with NPR, WCPN and Kaiser Health News.

Copyright 2015 Cleveland Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.wcpn.org.

Transcript

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

A construction project in the city of Cleveland has a story behind it - not a good. A new cancer center is being built. It's right around the corner from a competing cancer hospital built just four years ago. Here's the story. The hospitals may not have to compete for cancer patients. In Cleveland and elsewhere in the U.S., there is likely to be plenty of business to go around. Sarah Jane Tribble from member station WCPN reports.

SARAH JANE TRIBBLE, BYLINE: The Cleveland Clinic's nearly $300 million cancer center a slated to open in two years. A couple of backhoes move supplies around the vast hole in the ground, and it's difficult to imagine that a seven-story glass building will take the hole's place. Cliff Kazmierczak with Turner Construction points to Cleveland's gray sky and traces a silhouette with his fingertips.

CLIFF KAZMIERCZAK: There will also be skylights that'll be located just a little bit south of where this crane is situated right now.

TRIBBLE: Kazmierczak knows a thing or two about construction projects for cancer. He came to this project after overseeing construction at the cancer hospital at Ohio State University a few hours south of here.

KAZMIERCZAK: The big thing is to make the patient comfortable with the treatments that they're going through. So lighting and light colors, as much natural light as possible are always very important to cancer patients.

TRIBBLE: Across the country the health care industry is building up to take care of an influx of cancer patients. The Advisory Board consults for hospitals and doctors. Last year, they found that about 25 percent of its members with oncology services were either constructing a cancer center or had built one in the past three years. The board's Deirdre Fuller says people are more likely to get cancer as they get older.

DEIRDRE FULLER: Now that everyone is looking forward and seeing the aging of the baby boomers, it's certainly adding some fuel to that fire.

TRIBBLE: And most boomers will get health insurance through Medicare, which is a steady paycheck for hospitals. Dr. Brian Bolwell is chair the Cleveland Clinic's cancer center. He says hospitals have to meet the need.

BRIAN BOLWELL: In the past five years, volumes go up, depending on location, between five and 10 percent a year, and there's no end in sight to that volume growth.

TRIBBLE: The Cleveland Clinic, along with local competitor university hospitals, treat about 70 percent of the region's cancer patients. And when the Cleveland Clinic opens its new center, the two will be about five minutes from each other. But Dr. Nathan Levitan with University Hospitals doesn't seem worried about the competition. His 4-year-old hospital, he says, is basically full every day.

NATHAN LEVITAN: We discharged over 11,000 patients with cancer in 2014, which is about a 20 percent increase over just a few years beforehand.

TRIBBLE: That's because both hospitals employ and contract with thousands of doctors, and in the world of cancer care, doctors have a lot of influence, says Levitan. People usually don't shop for cancer treatment until they are diagnosed, and at that moment, their doctor's advice on where to go matters a lot. Bill Ryan leads a hospital advocacy group in Cleveland. He says with so many expected patients, hospitals can afford to - and should - build.

BILL RYAN: If you can run enough procedures through a facility, you're going to get some economies of scale that will generate margin. The other thing you get when you run enough procedures through a facility is a level of expertise that improves the quality of care that the individual gets.

TRIBBLE: And when talking about cancer's future, hospital leaders tend to talk about quality of care and insist that focusing on quality will eventually lower cost for patients. For NPR News, I'm Sarah Jane Tribble in Cleveland.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

GREENE: The story you just heard is part of a reporting partnership between NPR, WCPN and Kaiser Health News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Support your
public radio station