California's Legislature Debates Bill To Legalize Physician-Assisted Suicide

California's Legislature Debates Bill To Legalize Physician-Assisted Suicide

1:42pm Sep 12, 2015

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit



A controversial bill that would legalize physician-assisted suicide in California was passed by the state legislature today. If Governor Jerry Brown signs it, that state would be the fifth in the country to allow doctors to prescribe lethal medication to terminally ill patients who request it. Reporter April Dembosky at KQED in San Francisco has been following this debate all year. And April, help us understand the details here. What exactly would the bill allow if it becomes law?

APRIL DEMBOSKY, BYLINE: The bill is intended for patients who have six months or less to live. And the idea is really for patients who are very near death - maybe weeks away - whose suffering has become unbearable or intolerable. They could ask their doctor for drugs that would end their lives. But there are a lot of rules around it.

So first of all, patients have to be physically able to swallow the drugs themselves. And also, they have to be mentally capable of making medical decisions. So this is not something for Alzheimer's patients. It's not something for people who suffer from severe depression.

CORNISH: And this bill has actually failed a few times this year. What's changed?

DEMBOSKY: Right. So the proponents were able to get this through in a special legislative session. So during the regular legislative session, they hit a roadblock in the Assembly Health Committee. They didn't have enough votes to get it through. But then, the governor called a special session to discuss health care financing, and that's the way they were able to reintroduce this bill. And the makeups of the committees were different, so they were able to get it through this time.

CORNISH: What are the concerns that opponents have to this bill?

DEMBOSKY: Most of the opposition has come from religious groups who say only God can decide, you know, when a person's life is going to end and also from disability rights groups. They're particularly concerned about the potential for abuse and coercion. So say a person who's concerned about being a financial burden on their family - they're afraid that they will either choose or be pressured into taking these life-ending drugs instead of pursuing, say, more expensive life-sustaining treatments.

CORNISH: So how would the legislation address that?

DEMBOSKY: Well, there are number of protections that have been added over the last couple of months of debate in order to sway opponents. For example, the bill makes it a felony for a health insurance company, for example, who may want to deny treatment or coverage based on whether a patient seeks these drugs or not. Patients also have to ask for the drugs three times before they can get them, once in writing in front of two witnesses.

CORNISH: And we mentioned Governor Jerry Brown. Is there any sense about what he might do?

DEMBOSKY: You know, we really don't know. We know that the office was not very happy with the political pathway. They didn't think this was the appropriate - that this special session was the appropriate venue to discuss this issue. But that being said, Governor Brown has not indicated where he stands on the issue itself, whether or not he's going to sign or veto it. We do know if he does nothing in 30 days, the bill will become law.

CORNISH: That's April Dembosky with member station KQED in San Francisco. She comes to us as part of a partnership with Kaiser Health News. April, thank you.

DEMBOSKY: Thank you. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Support your
public radio station