Boeing Case Is Latest Targeting 401(k) Plans With Excessive Fees

Boeing Case Is Latest Targeting 401(k) Plans With Excessive Fees

6:20pm Aug 28, 2015

Boeing is moving to settle a lawsuit accusing it of mishandling its 401(k) plan for thousands of workers. The case is part of a legal assault by a consumer rights attorney to stop companies from offering employees high-cost, bad retirement plans.

Under federal law, employers are required to act in their workers' best interests in retirement plans, though it's not enforced very much by regulators. But Jerry Schlichter, a consumer rights lawyer in St. Louis, has sued a series of companies to force the issue.

It's earning Schlichter the nickname "the 401(k) Lone Ranger."

"Yes, that's what I have been called and I've always represented workers and I see how important it is that workers not be ripped off by their employer in their 401(k) plan," he says.

If a company does right by its workers, it finds low-cost, well diversified, smart investment choices, many experts say. But Schlichter says some companies offer workers mutual funds with fees that are way too high. Sometimes, he says, the companies get kickbacks for that.

And over time, he says, "it's hugely devastating. A 1 percent difference in fees over a 35-year work career makes a 28 percent difference in the retirement assets available to that worker. So this is huge. It may mean that the employee has to extend their work another six or seven years instead of retiring when they wanted to or their lifestyle in retirement is severely hurt."

Schlichter and Boeing aren't commenting on this case because the details are being worked out. Before the settlement, the aerospace giant had said its retirement plan was in keeping with best practices.

Schlichter has sued Lockheed Martin, Ameriprise Financial and six other large firms that have settled for a total of $200 million. About a third goes to the law firm and the rest goes to the affected workers. Schlichter says the settlements also mandated reforms at the companies that are enforced by the federal courts.

All these cases involve big companies. But Ian Ayres, a professor at Yale Law School who researches 401(k) plans, says that smaller employers "tend to have an even larger problem with excess fees."

He says that generally, if you're paying less than 0.5 percent in fees total for your investments, you're doing well. But if you're paying more than 1 percent, you're losing a lot of money over time.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

Now we're going to meet an attorney on a mission. He wants to stop companies from offering their employees high-cost bad retirement plans. Boeing has been one of his targets. And now the aerospace company is moving to settle a lawsuit accusing it of mishandling 401(k) plans for thousands of workers. NPR's Chris Arnold reports.

CHRIS ARNOLD, BYLINE: Under federal law, employers are required to act in their workers' best interests in retirement plans. It's not enforce very much by regulators, but a consumer rights lawyer in St. Louis named Jerry Schlichter has sued a series of companies now to force the issue. This is earnings Schlichter the nickname of the 401(k) Lone Ranger.

JERRY SCHLICHTER: Yes, that's what I have been called. And I've always represented workers, and I see how important it is that workers not be ripped off by their employer in their 401(k) plan.

ARNOLD: OK. Here's how this works. If a company does right by its workers, many experts say it finds low-cost, well-diversified, smart investment choices. But Schlichter says some companies offer workers mutual funds with fees that are way too high. Sometimes, he says, the companies get kickbacks for that, and over time...

SCHLICHTER: It's usually devastating. A 1 percent difference in fees over a 35-year work career makes a 28 percent difference in the retirement assets available to that worker. So this is huge. It may mean that the employee has to extend their work another six or seven years instead of retiring when they wanted to or their lifestyle in retirement is severely hurt.

ARNOLD: Schlichter and Boeing are note commenting on this case 'cause the details are still being worked out. Before the settlement, Boeing had said its retirement plan was in keeping with best practices. Schlichter's already sued Lockheed Martin, Ameriprise Financial and six other large firms that have settled for a total of $200 million. About a third of that goes to the law firm. Two-thirds go to the workers. Schlichter says the settlements also mandated reforms at the companies that are enforce by the federal courts. Now, all these cases involve big companies, but...

IAN AYRES: Smaller employers tend to have an even larger problem with excess fees.

ARNOLD: That's Ian Ayres, a professor at Yale Law School. He researcher 401(k) plans. He says a good rule of thumb - if you're paying less than half of 1 percent in fees total for your investments, you're doing well. But if you're paying more than 1 percent, you're losing a lot of money over time. Chris Arnold, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Support your
public radio station