Avian Flu Outbreak Takes Poultry Producers Into Uncharted Territory

Avian Flu Outbreak Takes Poultry Producers Into Uncharted Territory

4:25pm May 21, 2015
"No trespassing" signs are posted on the edge of a field at a farm operated by Daybreak Foods near Eagle Grove, Iowa, which has been designated "bio security area," on May 17.
"No trespassing" signs are posted on the edge of a field at a farm operated by Daybreak Foods near Eagle Grove, Iowa, which has been designated "bio security area," on May 17.
Scott Olson / Getty Images

An avian flu outbreak is sweeping across the Midwest at a frightening pace, ravaging chicken and turkey farms and leaving officials stumped about the virus's seemingly unstoppable spread.

Now reaching to 15 states, the outbreak has been detected at 174 farms, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. Because there's no vaccine, infected and even healthy birds must be killed to try to stop the virus, forcing the killing of 38.9 million birds and counting, the USDA says.

The particular strain of avian flu, highly pathogenic H5N2, was first confirmed in a backyard flock in Washington state. While chickens and turkeys are highly susceptible to it, it is considered a low risk for transmission to humans, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Now officials are scrambling, trying to figure out how to dispose of millions of dead birds. Most of them are in Iowa, the largest egg producer in the U.S. and the one hardest hit by the outbreak. At one farm alone, Rembrandt Enterprises, some 5.5 million birds had to be destroyed.

"I've been in the landfill business probably 26 years, and I've never ever seen this kind of volume," said Randy Oldenkamp, director of the Northwest Iowa Area Solid Waste Agency. "And I hope I never do again."

Oldenkamp is accepting 100 loads of the birds for disposal at 15 tons a load. But other landfill managers are turning away the birds, fearing contamination and neighbors' complaints.

"It is a catastrophe," said Billy Duplechein, who works with Clean Harbors, the contractor hired by the federal government to do the cleanup. "Nobody wants to see this kind of stuff, but something has to be done."

The USDA believes the virus was brought to the Midwest by migratory water fowl via the Mississippi Flyway. But Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack has admitted that the ongoing and quick spread could be "laterally spread" by people.

"We've had circumstances recently where folks have been using pond water, for example, to feed and to water their birds. Well, that's a problem because the pond water could be contaminated," Vilsack said. "We've had situations where folks are supposed to shower before they go into the facility, but the shower doesn't work, so they go in anyway."

"No trespassing" signs are posted on the edge of a field at a farm operated by Daybreak Foods near Eagle Grove, Iowa, which has been designated "bio security area," on May 17.

Scott Olson/Getty Images

Michael Osterholm, director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota, said the poultry industry is in uncharted territory. The virus is "doing things we've never seen it do before," so scientists' understanding is very limited, he says.

"Influenza viruses have thought in the past to be transmitted by birds to birds in close contact and that it was only through that kind of transmission that we need to be concerned," Osterholm says. "Now we surely have a very dynamic situation in the Midwest. It's also a situation where we no longer can assume it's just migratory birds."

Other theories on the virus's rapid transmission include small rodents infiltrating facilities, contaminated feed and water or that the virus could even be airborne.

Vilsack and Iowa Gov. Terry Branstad took to the media this week, begging landfills to take the birds before any more can be exposed. Farms are also burying the birds, composting them with wood chips and corn stover and burning them in five large mobile incinerators brought in by Clean Harbors. Officials are also considering taking mobile incinerators from farm to farm.

Northwest Iowa is hardest hit, thanks to its large egg-laying operations, and workers in white and yellow Tyvek suits, protective gear with a respirator, could be seen discarding the birds from barns.

Neighbors in the remote rural communities say they have noticed more trucks at the farms. And they've certainly noticed the putrid smell.

Dawn Cronk lives just a mile and a half south of Sunrise Farms, near Harris, Iowa, and drives home at midnight from her job working the late shift at a nursing home.

"I have the window down and all of a sudden there's just that distinct dead animal smell," she says. "And it's not just one dead animal, it's like you walked into a ... a decomposing lot. It's just that strong."

A huge incinerator is being set up at the Cherokee County landfill, and officials there plan to fire it up this week and have it burning for 24 hours a day. Although some hold out hope that the outbreak will die down this summer, when its harder for the virus to live in hot temperatures, others guess that states could be cleaning up for months or even years to come.

"That's the million-dollar question," Duplechein says. "We really don't know."

This story comes to us via Harvest Public Media.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

We are tracking a disease that has killed tens of millions of birds.

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

It's this nation's worst epidemic of avian influenza, or bird flu. It took hold in the upper Midwest.

INSKEEP: And it's left some 38 million chickens and turkeys dead. Some were killed by the flu, and others were killed to stop it from spreading.

MONTAGNE: It may, in time, affect your grocery bill. Scientists say this outbreak is spreading in a way they've never seen before. Here's Iowa Public Radio's Sarah Boden.

SARAH BODEN, BYLINE: I'm sitting in the tall grass on the banks of Jensen Marsh in southern Iowa, and everywhere I look, I see a bird. There's a bunch of red-wing blackbirds. And earlier today, there were some raptors circling overhead. And there are a lot of ducks today. Migratory waterfowl tends to stop here on their way north to summer nesting grounds.

MICHAEL OSTERHOLM: Influenza viruses have thought in the past to be transmitted by birds to birds in close contact and that it was only through that kind of transmission that we need to be concerned. Now we surely have a very dynamic situation in the Midwest. It's also a situation where we no longer can just assume this is all migratory birds.

BODEN: That's Dr. Michael Osterholm who studies infectious diseases at the University of Minnesota. This particular strain moving through the Midwest is called H5N2. It mutated from another strain of influenza that was carried by birds from Asia to North America. Any number of theories could explain the virus's rapid transmission. It could be humans carrying it or small rodents infiltrating facilities to contaminated feed and water. The virus could even be airborne. Osterholm says the poultry industry is in uncharted territories.

OSTERHOLM: The virus is doing things that we've never seen it do before. Because we don't understand that, our understanding of what we can do about it is also very limited.

BODEN: This January saw the first confirmed case in a backyard flock in Washington state. Today, there are nearly 170 confirmed outbreaks. Less than an hour's drive from a commercial egg-laying facility that was hit by the virus in early May, I meet up with Dale Raasch, an organic poultry producer. He keeps a flock of about 550 chickens, mostly for eggs. Because of avian flu, Raasch no longer allows most people on his property. So instead, we talk on the side of a gravel road right in front of a little country cemetery. This is also the spot Raasch meets his farm-to-table distributor.

DALE RAASCH: They've got two or three other places that they stop at that has chickens. And I just feel that it's better not to have them come on our place.

BODEN: Before avian flu, Raasch's chickens were allowed to range freely on his property. Now they have to stay in the shed.

RAASCH: When you come and open the door, they think that they're going to be able to get out and get to eat some green grass and stuff and roam around. And they're really disappointed when they don't get to go out of the shed.

BODEN: Some people think Raasch is going too far, but USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack says the most important thing producers can do now is focus on biosecurity.

TOM VILSACK: Folks have been using pond water, for example, to feed and to water their birds. Well, that's a problem because the pond water could be contaminated. We've had situations where folks are supposed to shower before they go into facility, but the shower doesn't work so they go in anyway.

BODEN: The majority of affected birds have been in Iowa, the country's leading egg producer. Egg prices have started to increase at the retail level. Part of this may be due to hoarding. Bakers, restaurants, food manufacturers and other buyers of liquid eggs are also starting to see a price increase. Costs may not soar because avian flu hasn't struck farmers in other leading egg-producing states like Ohio and Pennsylvania. Michael Osterholm says most troubling is the possibility that this strain could be airborne.

OSTERHOLM: We know for other plant pathogens, infectious agents of plants, that we can see clouds of material literally coming across from Africa, across the equator into South America on the wind. And I think the real question here is if that's what's happening here. If it is, that really poses a unique challenge to us for in terms of trying to prevent future transmission.

BODEN: The USDA says new outbreaks will likely ease this summer because exposure to hot, dry weather and direct sunlight kills the virus. But if it is wild birds carrying the flu, when they migrate south for the winter, we may see a new series of outbreaks. And while the virus has mostly affected egg-laying hens, by fall, turkeys and chickens raised for meat on the East Coast could be affected. For NPR News, I'm Sarah Boden in Des Moines. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Support your
public radio station